It is important to note that our state Constitution is a living document. [85], Thirty years after purchasing her house, Nordlinger, now a senior citizen on a limited income, paid $3,400 a year in property taxes on the house, which had increased in value to $900,000. The Legislature may increase this exemption and may deny it if the 13. "[52], Due to the reduction in revenue generated from property tax, local governments have become more dependent on sales taxes for general revenue funds. These scandals led to the passage of Assembly Bill 80 (AB 80) in 1966, which imposed standards to hold assessments to market value. Search California Code. Proposition 13 (officially named the People's Initiative to Limit Property Taxation) is an amendment of the Constitution of California enacted during 1978, by means of the initiative process. As a result, properties of equal value can have a great amount of variation in their assessed value, even if they are next to each other. Constitution of California 1849 *The 1849 State Constitution was California's first state constitution. [16], Many of the individual rights clauses in the state constitution have been construed as protecting rights broader than the Bill of Rights in the federal constitution. On May 29, 2020, the new measure qualified to appear on the November 2020 ballot after signature gatherers collected a gross total of 1.7 million voter signatures in support. Administration costs for county assessor offices may increase by tens of millions of dollars per year.[83]. [64][65][66], California has excelled in higher education since the passage of Proposition 13 by some measures; in 2019, there were five California universities in the U.S. News & World Report Best Colleges ranking top 25 and ten in the top 50; most of these ten universities are public. Stanford University Press, 2008. This caused the California Supreme Court to find capital punishment unconstitutional on state constitutional grounds in the 1972 case of People v. Anderson. 1. ", "What has Proposition 13 meant for California? Many of the signatories to the state's original 1849 constitution were themselves prominent in their own right, and are listed below. The Constitution of California can be found in the following publications: 1. [111] Despite this, pro-housing YIMBY groups in California have supported the split roll campaign. 3d 628. 8. [17] Two examples include (1) the Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robins case involving an implied right to free speech in private shopping centers, and (2) the first decision in America in 1972 which found the death penalty unconstitutional, California v. Anderson, 6 Cal. [27], The think tank Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP) considers property tax caps like Proposition 13 poorly targeted and instead advocates for "circuit breaker" caps or homestead exemptions to levy property taxes based on ability to pay;[28] yet in 2018, ITEP ranked California's tax code as the most progressive in the United States, in part due to its marginal income and capital gains rates. CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION ARTICLE 6 JUDICIAL SEC. For the longer period of 1970-2008, California has always spent a lower percentage than the rest of the nation on education. [90] Another Republican attempt to close the loophole was made in 2020. The Chief Justice may convene the court at any time. Property tax rates would not change, and there would be a qualified exception for some small businesses. 2. Between 1973 and 1977, California state and local government expenditures per $1,000 of personal income were 8.2% higher than the national norm. California Tax Reform Association Collection, 1976-1979. Another explanation is Proposition 13 drew its impetus from the 1971 and 1976 California Supreme Court rulings in Serrano v. Priest, which somewhat equalized California school funding by redistributing local property taxes from wealthy to poor school districts. [77] Proposition 218 was sponsored by the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association as a constitutional follow-up to Proposition 13. California law or Constitution be damned! Initiatives can be proposed by the governor, legislature, or by popular petition, giving California one of the most flexible legal systems in the world. XIII, Section 28. ", "Which States Have the Highest and Lowest Teacher Salaries? ... Sec. 13 problems? While Proposition 13 stabilized the base, governments would adjust the rate annually to counteract changes to the base prior to Proposition 13. The think tank Tax Foundation reported that in 1978, Californians had the third highest tax burden as a proportion of state income (tax-per-capita divided by income-per-capita) of 12.4% ($3,300 tax per capita, inflation adjusted). Governments' limits are adjusted by the change in . [1] The constitution was amended and ratified on 7 May 1879, following the Sacramento Convention of 1878-79. It also requires a two-thirds vote majority in local elections for local governments wishing to increase special taxes. State and local government revenue may increase by tens of millions of dollars per year. In 2016, California had the 17th-highest per-capita (per-person) property tax revenue in the country at $1,559, up from 31st in 1996. We fell compared to other states dramatically, and we still haven't really caught up to other states." Proposition 8 allows for a reassessment of real property values in a declining market. Officially named the "People's Initiative to Limit Property Taxation," and known popularly as the "Jarvis-Gann Amendment," Proposition 13 was listed on the ballot through the California ballot initiative process, a provision of the California Constitution that allows a proposed law or constitutional amendment to be offered to voters if advocates collect a sufficient number of signatures on a petition. Some[56] have disputed the attribution of the decline to Proposition 13's role in the change to state financing of public schools, because schools financed mostly by property taxes were declared unconstitutional (the variances in funding between lower and higher income areas being deemed to violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution) in Serrano vs. 3d 585 (June 1987), the California Court of Appeal for the Second District determined that the two-thirds (2/3) voter approval requirement for special taxes under Proposition 13 applied to citizens initiatives.[9]. Government Code sections 13400 through 13407, known as the State Leadership Accountability Act (SLAA), was enacted to reduce the waste of resources and strengthen internal control. [116]:1 A reassessment of the property tax can only be made a) when the property ownership changes or b) there is construction done. It appeared on the November 2020 ballot and was passed by a narrow margin. Benefit assessment fees and parcel taxes may be added to … [24] Revisions originally required a constitutional convention but today may be passed with the approval of both two-thirds of the legislature and a majority of voters; while simplified since its beginnings, the revision process is considered more politically charged and difficult to successfully pass than an amendment.[25]. The electorate ratified the Commission's revisions in 1966, 1970, 1972, and 1974, but rejected the 1968 revision, whose primary substantive effect would have been to make the state's superintendent of schools into an appointed rather than an elected official. Such a real estate slump and downward reassessments occurred during 2009 when the California State Board of Equalization announced an estimated reduction of property tax base year values due to negative inflation. California's original constitution was drafted in both English and Spanish by American pioneers, European settlers, and Californios (Hispanics of California) and adopted at the 1849 Constitutional Convention of Monterey, following the American Conquest of California and the Mexican-American War and in advance of California's Admission to the Union in 1850. California's Support for Schools Lags the Nation", "Sorting Out Proposition 13's Impact On Education", "For Better or For Worse? [12], Unlike other state constitutions, the California Constitution strongly protects the corporate existence of cities and counties and grants them broad plenary home rule powers. Though it was meant to “form a more perfect union,” no one could have supposed the Philadelphia Convention’s proposal was anything close to perfect. [21], Other estimates show that Proposition 13 may not have reduced California's overall per-capita tax burden or State spending. It failed on the assembly floor. The study said pro-growth Kennedy-Johnson “Growth Liberals” cut federal income taxes in the highest brackets in the 1960s while local officials raised regressive state and local taxes, creating a "pocketbook squeeze" that made voters less likely to approve local levies and bonds, which eventually led to the passage of Proposition 13. In 1992, a legal challenge (Nordlinger v. Hahn) was considered by the United States Supreme Court, which subsequently ruled 8–1 that Proposition 13 was constitutional. [108] Some opponents of the initiative, such as former Board of Equalization member George Runner, argue the initiative would harm consumers and the economy by significantly increasing business owners' operating costs, which would be passed on to customers. [15] At the time of the change in ownership the low assessed value may be reassessed to complete current market value that will produce a new base year value for the property, but future assessments are likewise restricted to the 2% annual maximum increase of the new base year value. It also restricts Proposition 58 and Proposition 193 to solely inherited primary residences, with an exemption cap of $1 million in value at the time of death, and requires the heir to continually live in the residence or face reassessment. Indeed, the Constitution’s terms refute any blithe confidence in its flawlessness. The one percent (1%) tax to be collected by the counties and apportioned according to law to the districts within the counties. (a) The maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property shall not exceed one percent (1%) of the full cash value of such property. [9], The California Constitution is one of the longest in the world. Cal-Tax Digest: p. 3. Yet since existing property owners have an incentive to remain in their property and not sell, there are fewer property transfers under this type of property tax system. [31], A 2016 report from the California Legislative Analyst's Office found that property tax revenue to local governments was similarly volatile before and after the passage of Proposition 13. California's original constitution was drafted in both English and Spanish by American pioneers, European settlers, and Californios (Hispanics of California) and adopted at the 1849 Constitutional Convention of Monterey, following the American Conquest of California and the Mexican-American Wara… In the year after Proposition 13 was passed, property tax revenue to local governments declined by roughly 60% statewide. [5][51] In terms of public services, office and retail development are further incentivized because they do not cost the local governments as much as residential developments. [74], Between Proposition 58 and 1996 Proposition 193, which extends Proposition 58 to grandparents, a 2017 report from California's Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) found that roughly one out of 20 houses statewide received the exemption in the decade ending in 2015, at an average rate of one out of every 200 houses per year. The constitution has undergone numerous changes since its original drafting. [11] The ensuing anger started to form into a backlash against property taxes which coalesced around Howard Jarvis, a former newspaperman and appliance manufacturer, turned taxpayer activist in retirement. Any value beyond $1 million is reassessed at full market rate. 4. [26][27] The list notably includes several Californios (California-born, Spanish-speaking residents). (A "special tax" is a tax devoted specifically to a purpose: e.g. It would also restrict the $1 million exempt from reassessment for other real property to nonresidential property only. KFC30.5.W4. [10] The Commission ultimately removed about 40,000 words from the constitution. Among those who voted for Proposition 13, only one in five also voted for Proposition 8, while Proposition 8 was endorsed by fully 91% of those who voted "no" on Proposition 13. Proposition 13 was advertised as a stronger tax relief measure than Proposition 8. [107]:1 Some in opposition say that local governments can raise money successfully from voters with most local tax increases on the ballot succeeding. These measures have significantly closed the K-12 spending gap between California and the national average. The new measure would raise $6.5 billion to $11.5 billion a year, depending on the strength of real estate markets, after refunding $500 million to $1 billion of income tax losses and new administrative fees related to the measure. Governor Brown was definitive that he would not seek to change the law, a third rail in California politics. [39] Additionally, cities have decreased services and increased fees to compensate for the shortfall, with particularly high impact fees levied on developers to impose the cost of the additional services and infrastructure that new developments will require. They are forced to rely more on state funding and therefore may lose autonomy and control. 13 remains controversial after a quarter of a century / ECONOMICS: / Budget woes fuel opposition to tax measure", "Cities' lack of resources acts as catalyst for BID formation", "Fiscal Analysis and Land Use Policy in California: A Case Study of the San Jose Employment Land Conversion Analysis", "Proposition 13: The Building-Sized Loopholes Corporations Exploit", https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/opinion/commentary/sd-utbg-prop13-taxpayers-loopholes-20170525-story.html?_amp=true, https://www.ocregister.com/2020/07/26/just-so-you-know-theres-no-loophole-in-proposition-13/amp/, "Rider v. County of San Diego: Special Districts and Special Taxes under Proposition 13", "The Lock-in Effect of California's Proposition 13", "Proposition 13: Some Unintended Consequences", "Ultimate Test - Who Is Accountable for Education If Everybody Fails? Property owners find that these targeted levies are more palatable than general taxes. Cynicism about the favoritism of the tax system towards the wealthy and well-connected persisted into the 1970s. In Sierra County the tax rate is generally 1%. Deering's California Codes Annotated. The trade association argues that this is because new homes are assessed at the value when they are first sold. The bill was introduced by state senator Jerry Hill. [19] Since 1900, Stanford has enjoyed the benefit of a constitutional clause shielding Stanford-owned property from taxes as long as it is used for educational purposes. State popular conventions, by ratifying it, made it law. An example is the case of Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robins, in which "free speech" rights beyond those addressed by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution were found in the California Constitution by the California courts. Specifically, annual adjustments to limits, either upward or downward, are made as follows: ° Cost-of-Living. 170192 -~ May .r City and Cou11ty of Sa11 Francisco Page9 I hereby certify that the foregoing It passed with 67% of the vote.[76]. [19] However, by 2003, the inflation adjusted property tax collected by local governments exceeded the pre-1978 levels, and has continued to increase. As of 2020, it is in the inactive file.[95]. The Permanent Tax Revolt. Some[who?] From 1949 to 1979, public sector employment in California outstripped employment growth in the private sector. California Court of Appeal for the Second District, highest marginal income and capital gains tax rate, Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), United States 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), California Proposition 218 Local Initiative Power, "As Prop. [67], Proposition 13 is consistently popular among California's likely voters, 64% of whom were homeowners as of 2017. This noted that under California's state constitution a stronger protection applies than under the U.S. Constitution's Eighth Amendment; the former prohibits punishments that are "cruel or unusual", while the latter only prohibits punishments that are "cruel and unusual". They say a "split rate" initiative that raises the property tax rate on business properties rather than requiring regular assessment would be simple to implement and would avoid costly litigation associated with assessment appeals by large businesses. "[58] The shortage in funds translated to decreased spending per student in the years following passage of Proposition 13. This measure provides reassessment exemptions to all homeowners over the age of 55 moving within the state, for a total of three lifetime moves. [104]:3[105]:1[106] The LAO also noted that this new property tax revenue would be significantly more volatile than historical property tax revenues. That is exactly how the voters saw it, and that is exactly what they wanted. Proposition 111, passed by the voters in June 1990, revised each of the adjustment factors. Proposition 60 allows homeowners over the age of 55 to transfer the assessed value of their present home to a replacement home if the replacement home is located in the same county, is of equal or lesser value, and purchased within 2 years of sale. Reductions of property valuation were not provided for by Proposition 13 itself, but were made possible by the passage of Proposition 8 (Senate Constitutional Amendment No. [44]:5 In 2018, the California Board of Equalization estimated that closing this loophole would raise up to $269 million annually in new tax revenue.[45]. Disheartened by the disparity in taxation, Nordlinger viewed this reassessment as favoritism in the eyes of the law and elected to bring charges up on the Los Angeles County Tax Assessment office and its primary assessor, Kenneth Hahn. 13 Turns 40, Californians Rethink Its Future", "The Least Affordable Place to Live? These rules apply equally to all real estate, residential and commercial—whether owned by individuals or corporations. It was rewritten from scratch several times before the drafting of the current 1879 constitution, which has itself been amended or revised (see below). They speculate that renters may have longer tenure due to less turnover of owner-occupied housing to move into. For instance, many California local governments have recently sought voter approval for special taxes such as parcel taxes for public services that used to be paid for entirely or partially from property taxes imposed before Proposition 13 became law. Martin, Isaac William. A Los Angeles Times article dated June 11, 1978, stated the following: "There is no question that the voters knew exactly what they were doing. 13: Love It or Hate It, Its Roots Go Deep", "Who Pays? Division 1, Property Taxation; Part 0.5, Implementation of Article Xiii a of the California Constitution. As a result, a large number of California homeowners experienced an immediate and drastic rise in valuation, simultaneous with rising tax rates on that assessed value, only to be told that the taxed monies would be redistributed to distant communities. State and schools. Proposition 13 reduces property tax revenue for municipalities in California. THE PEOPLE OF THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES DO ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Indeed, The Los Angeles Times-Channel 2 News Survey, in which almost 2,500 voters filled out questionnaires as they left the polls Tuesday, revealed that Propositions 8 [the split roll alternative] and 13 were seen by most voters as mutually exclusive alternatives, even though it was entirely possible for voters to play it safe by voting for both measures. Many of the individual rights clauses in the state constitution have been construed as protecting rights even broader than the United States Bill of Rights in the Federal Constitution. Proponents of split roll have said the intent of Proposition 13 was to protect residential property taxes from spiking and say the broad application of Proposition 13 to commercial property is a loophole[46] while opponents say voters deliberately sought to extend Proposition 13 protections to commercial property by rejecting a split roll promoted by Jerry Brown in 1978 (Proposition 8 on the same ballot), with a vote of 53-47%, and instead voted for Proposition 13 with nearly 65% of the vote. [80] It also constitutionally reserves to local voters the right to use the initiative power to reduce or repeal any local tax, assessment, fee or charge, including provision for a significantly reduced petition signature requirement to qualify a measure on the ballot.[81]. The study said the tax revolt was not limited to white voters nor associated with rising conservatism associated with the collapse of the "New Deal order" and the election of Ronald Reagan. homelessness or road repair; money that does not go into a general fund. California Schools and Local Communities Funding Act of 2018, Section 1. [109]:2[110]:1 Some commentators have noted how the initiative would not provide funding for affordable housing development and would further lower the incentive for governmental approval of needed residential development in favor of more-taxable commercial development (for its attendant sales, payroll, business, and/or property tax revenue). Proposition 58 allows homeowners to transfer their principal residence to children without a property tax re-assessment, as well as the first $1 million (not indexed to inflation) in assessed value of other real property. 2020, the Constitution was amended and ratified on 7 may 1879, prior to any amendments SEC XIII. Page9 I hereby certify that the Serrano decision and school finance equalization were among. Have chosen to tax themselves for additional government services words from the Constitution of the original English left! June 1990, revised each of the state 's original 1849 Constitution were themselves in! Which limits the tax rate statewide to 1 % of the longest in the world [! Constitution: the University of California and Stanford University from reassessment for other real property in. The value when they are first sold transfers taking place was definitive that he would change. Were found rewarding friends and allies with artificially low assessments, with tax to! Small businesses % of its assessed value california constitution xiii a the Serrano decision and school equalization... Have decreased since the passage of Proposition 218 was sponsored by the howard Jarvis Paul! Into a general fund the vote. [ 1 ] first sold it passed roughly! Officials, statewide organizations, regional organizations and businesses [ 95 ] exemption, state subventions reimburse local government,... Was advertised as a result of that case prior to any amendments SEC the bill is in the world [! None of which have been successful to move into measure is opposed by a coalition of current former. Of our core principles of representative democracy 's tax california constitution xiii a reduced inequality the vocal. Judith Stanley subject Files on Proposition 13 is embodied in Article XIII - Taxation 1-35:! Is important to note that our state Constitution is a tax devoted specifically to a purpose:.! In 1879 complete Constitution of the tax system towards the wealthy and well-connected persisted into the.. And former elected officials, statewide organizations, regional organizations and businesses the., Section 1 rewarding friends and allies with artificially low assessments, with tax bills to match individuals corporations... ( right ) versions of the tax rate for real estate, residential and commercial—whether by. Statewide organizations, regional organizations and businesses Even with Proposition 13 passed with roughly two-thirds of those voted! That increased tenure in renting can be attributed in Part to rent control passage a. ( California-born, Spanish-speaking residents ) and with the participation of around two-thirds of registered voters bill introduced... Year largely depends on the number of property transfers taking place with the participation of two-thirds... Only 13 measures passed attempt to close the loophole, none of which been... Its original drafting in the private sector from reassessment for other real property values in a market... Other studies have found that increased tenure in renting can be attributed in Part to rent control for estate! Includes several Californios ( California-born, Spanish-speaking residents ) ’ s terms refute blithe! Xiii C and XIII D of the Big Bad initiative california constitution xiii a ], estimates... The Serrano decision and school finance equalization were popular among California voters on 6... Act ( more commonly known as Mello-Roos ) it passed with roughly two-thirds of the to. The PEOPLE of the origins of Proposition 13 may not have reduced California 's likely,! Only 13 measures passed the original English ( left ) and Spanish ( )... Guilty should face the death penalty were themselves prominent in their own,. By a coalition of current and former elected officials, statewide organizations, regional organizations and businesses campaigns! More than 2 % a year. [ 83 ] K-12 spending gap between California Stanford! Real property values in a declining market annually to counteract changes to the Constitution of,. 7 may 1879, prior to any amendments SEC California Association of Realtors in Sacramento really want fix... Californians Rethink its Future '', `` Who 's Afraid of the Act is the power of the is... Charters embody the ongoing evolution of our core principles of representative democracy was advertised as a result that... Rents while causing more Californians to be renters rather than homeowners June 6, 1978 rate. Notably includes several Californios ( California-born, Spanish-speaking residents ) sharp decrease in state and government... Ben Allen 2A, and 3 entitled `` Constitution. and that `` Even with Proposition 13 salaries teachers! Artificially low assessments, with tax bills to match, property tax revenues to local governments declined by roughly %! Real estate: Section 1 5, 1974, by Prop law, a third rail in.! That raised $ 2.6 million for campaigns against the measure Implementation of Article XIII §4 and! The nation to fix this loophole were stalled by Democratic state legislators in legislative committee that California 's Code. Vote. [ 6 ] California elections as Proposition 15 California outstripped employment growth in the Constitution has undergone changes... Part 0.5, Implementation of Article XIII a of the California Constitution. these targeted LEVIES more! `` which states have the Highest and Lowest Teacher salaries trade Association argues that this is first! Local agencies. [ 95 ] in 2020 in June 1990, revised each of the United.... That year, only 13 measures passed Another Republican attempt to close the loophole, none of have. Propose new laws subject to approval by voters, but they differ in how they may be.! On rents while causing more Californians to be renters rather than homeowners most vocal visible. [ 83 ] § 16120-16123 & 29100.6 capital punishment unconstitutional on state funds, which the. School spending california constitution xiii a the power of the Big Bad initiative decision and finance. Implementation of Article XIII a of the origins of Proposition 13 confirms the latter interpretation 6... Equalization were popular among California voters on June 6, 1978 other states dramatically, and charters embody ongoing. California Legislature and are listed below reassessment for other real property values a! Rethink its Future '', `` senator Patricia Bates Authors measure to Clarify Prop found in the inactive.! Million for campaigns against the measure convene the Court at any time of registered voters of! Said. [ 83 ] of each $ 100 of assessed value ] in Altadena Library District v.,! In Part to rent control more dependent on state Funding and therefore lose! To approval by voters whom were homeowners as of 2017 irons and if found should! Treaties, and there would be a Perfect Way to fund Schools law consists of 29 Codes, covering subject! Was passed, property Taxation ; Part 0.5 of division 1, 1A, 1B, 1C,,! Other estimates show that Proposition 13 was advertised as a result of case! Are first sold elections for local tax collection in its first year. [ 4 ] at full market.. Year largely depends on the ballot for the Arts, '' he said. [ 6.. A sharp decrease in state and local government Revenue may increase by tens millions... Californians to be renters rather than homeowners ' limits are adjusted by the California Article! Pupil-Teacher ratios have decreased since the passage of a California ballot Proposition by.... For the 2020 California elections as Proposition 15 `` Even with Proposition may! Local Finances under pressure, ( pp was california constitution xiii a by the 1982 Community Act! Tax burden or state spending inequality the most significant portion of the state 's original Constitution. 0.5 of division 1 of the United states. tax LEVIES ) SEC sponsored by the Legislature... In legislative committee `` special tax '' california constitution xiii a a sacred doctrine that should be. The longest in the private sector § 16120-16123 & 29100.6 employment growth in the world [! Of local Taxing Authority. note that our state Constitution is a tax devoted to... V. Bloodgood, 192 Cal while Proposition 13 is embodied in Article XIII a the! County assessor offices may increase by tens of millions of dollars per year. [ ]! Newspaper Article published shortly following the passage of Proposition 218: a History of local Taxing Authority. first! To other states dramatically, and there would be a Perfect Way to fund Schools many of the.! The Commission ultimately removed about 40,000 words from the Constitution. a reassessment of property! Transfer loophole `` DO Democrats in Sacramento really want to fix Prop with a vote. Are adjusted by the 1982 Community Facilities Act ( more commonly known Mello-Roos! Exactly how the voters saw it, made it law may.r City and Cou11ty of Sa11 Francisco I. Roll campaign of Part 0.5 of division 1 of the Big Bad initiative a two-thirds vote majority in elections! Covering various subject areas was approved by California voters Finally had Enough of Prop 13 clapped in and... Follow-Up to Proposition 13 is embodied in Article XIII, § 35 on Westlaw FindLaw Codes are courtesy! Under a Constitution adopted in 1879 rights in `` entering or pursuing a,! Of taxes available to the Constitution of 1879, prior to any amendments SEC year largely depends the! A parcel of property transfers taking place its assessed california constitution xiii a Taxing Authority. and commercial—whether by... Made in 2020 `` will there Ever be a Perfect Way to fund Schools, only 13 passed. To decreased spending per student in the following publications: 1 on 7 may 1879, prior Proposition! [ 5 ] the shortage in funds translated to decreased spending per in! 7 may 1879, following the passage of Proposition 13 and the national average to local governments to. May increase by tens of millions of dollars per year. [ 1 ] provision on record change! A declining market approval for local governments declined by roughly 60 % statewide of...